An argument against the electoral college in the united states

an argument against the electoral college in the united states Republicans in both states have proposed abandoning the winner-take-all format for choosing electors, where all of the state's electoral votes go to the candidate who wins the statewide popular vote.

Lawsuits against the electoral college are extreme long shots and exactly what liberals need mr pence from ascending to the highest offices in the united states” these electors aren’t. Electoral college paper llerena bus 200 dr lasher 3/19/12 the electoral college is defined as “a body of electors chosen by the voters of each state to elect the president and vice president of the united states. Against the electoral college (people, not cows) 43 and consider whether you really want the united states to be more like brazil, mexico, turkey, the philippines, or zimbabwe it wasn’t meant to be in federalist paper #10, madison explains why part of his argument is that individual voters are not likely to be very well informed.

Minority interests must be protected against majority support for popular vote the electoral college is specifically designed to protect minority interests in the united states the fact that the majority of americans support a popular vote should not, therefore, be considered against the electoral college. Electoral college: electoral college, the system by which the president and vice president of the united states are chosen it was devised by the framers of the united states constitution to provide a method of election that was feasible, desirable, and consistent with a republican form of government for the results. According to critics, the electoral college is a faulty system that should be abolished and replaced by direct election supporters of the electoral college system make convincing arguments that it is the best system to decide the presidential election in a complex society such as the united states.

The founders who sat in the 1787 constitutional convention lavished an extraordinary amount of argument on the electoral college, and it was by no means one-sided. The electoral college is a method by which the president of the united states is elected that employs electoral votes instead of popular votes those electoral votes are loosely proportional to each state’s population and serve to grant slightly greater weight to those less populous states states that tend to be more agrarian in nature. There are three main arguments against ending the electoral college opponents first argue that the electoral college helps preserve the importance of — and issues vital to — smaller states , instead of allowing presidential candidates to focus mostly if not solely on the big cities. Core arguments for the electoral college are based on faulty premises the electoral college violates political equity and popular choice, but doesn’t provide any compensatory benefits. Here’s a quick list of the problems and potential problems.

How the terrible, skewed, anachronistic electoral college gave us trump once again, a democrat has won the popular vote but lost the election it is time to throw out this badly outdated institution. There are a number of arguments against it: if, like me, you are opposed to the electoral college system, i strongly recommend contacting your state representatives and asking them to support the national popular vote interstate compact to be clear, lest anyone misinterpret my answer, i am not. The problem with most of the arguments for the electoral college is that they prove too much, because if they were good arguments, every state is stupid, as no state has a mini electoral college. Right now, 11 states and the district of columbia are signed on to the national popular vote interstate compact, which awards states’ electoral votes to the candidate with the most votes nationwide. Moreover, if geographic spread is a good argument for a continental electoral college, why isn't it an equally good argument for an intrastate electoral college for vast and populous states like.

An argument against the electoral college in the united states

an argument against the electoral college in the united states Republicans in both states have proposed abandoning the winner-take-all format for choosing electors, where all of the state's electoral votes go to the candidate who wins the statewide popular vote.

The potential for the electoral college to conflict with the result of the popular vote is one of the most commonly cited arguments against the electoral college con 4: there’s the possibility of “rogue electors. The electoral college ensures that all parts of the country are involved in selecting the president of the united states if the election depended solely on the popular vote, then candidates could limit campaigning to heavily-populated areas or specific regions. Conservatives say the electoral college serves as a necessary bulwark against big states, preventing california in particular from imposing “something like colonial rule over the rest of the. Pols- 1100 persuasive essay- electoral college what should be done with the electoral college—keep it, reform it, or replace it with to mention that the states with the highest population would always have an advantage the only common argument against the electoral college that is worth changing the.

  • Some claim that the founding fathers chose the electoral college over direct election in order to balance the interests of high-population and low-population states.
  • Since 2000, a popular argument for the electoral college made on conservative websites and talk radio is that without the electoral college, candidates would spend all their time campaigning in.

- the electoral college the founding fathers wrote the electoral college into the united states constitution as insurance against popular passion electing the chief executive into office they believed there needed to be a buffer between the people and election of the president. Against these reasons to retain the electoral college the argument that it is undemocratic falls flat no form of representative democracy, as distinct from direct democracy, is or aspires to be. The fact that no state uses an electoral college for its governor suggests that many standard arguments for the electoral college — recount nightmares, fairness for rural areas, etc — are.

an argument against the electoral college in the united states Republicans in both states have proposed abandoning the winner-take-all format for choosing electors, where all of the state's electoral votes go to the candidate who wins the statewide popular vote. an argument against the electoral college in the united states Republicans in both states have proposed abandoning the winner-take-all format for choosing electors, where all of the state's electoral votes go to the candidate who wins the statewide popular vote. an argument against the electoral college in the united states Republicans in both states have proposed abandoning the winner-take-all format for choosing electors, where all of the state's electoral votes go to the candidate who wins the statewide popular vote. an argument against the electoral college in the united states Republicans in both states have proposed abandoning the winner-take-all format for choosing electors, where all of the state's electoral votes go to the candidate who wins the statewide popular vote.
An argument against the electoral college in the united states
Rated 4/5 based on 48 review

2018.